Studiegids met artikelsamenvattingen voor Filosofie voor pedagogen aan de Universiteit Leiden

Studiegids met artikelsamenvattingen

Samenvattingen per artikel bij Filosofie voor pedagogen

  • Voor samenvattingen bij de voorgeschreven artikelen van Filosofie voor pedagogen, zie de supporting content van deze studiegids

Inhoudsopgave

  • ADHD: a critical update for educational professionals
  • Philosophising with children
  • Between horror and boredom
  • Forever young

Gerelateerde samenvattingen en studiehulp

Supporting content I (full)
Article summary with ADHD: a critical update for educational professionals by Te Meerman a.o. - 2017

Article summary with ADHD: a critical update for educational professionals by Te Meerman a.o. - 2017

Introduction

This article aims to provide a critical update on Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) for educational professionals. The authors highlight that a medicalized approach to behavioral problems can make educators feel inadequate.

Objective

The article presents six science-based considerations regarding ADHD, the most prevalent childhood psychiatric diagnosis.

Method

The authors discuss six key aspects of ADHD:

  1. Neuropathology: The neurobiological basis of ADHD is complex, involving abnormalities in brain structure and function.
  2. Genetic Factors: There is a strong genetic component to ADHD, with a heritability estimate of 70-80%.
  3. Symptoms and Classification: ADHD symptoms are divided into two clusters: inattention and hyperactivity/impulsivity.
  4. Treatment: ADHD treatment involves medication, psychotherapy, and psychosocial interventions.
  5. Comorbidity: ADHD often co-occurs with other mental health conditions, such as learning disabilities, anxiety disorders, and mood disorders.
  6. Stigma: Stigma surrounding ADHD can lead to social and emotional problems in children.

Results

The authors discuss how misconceptions about ADHD can lead to stigma and misdiagnosis. They emphasize the importance of a multidisciplinary approach to ADHD management.

Key Considerations for Educators

  • Moving Beyond Misconceptions: The article emphasizes that common misconceptions about ADHD, such as solely attributing it to bad behavior, can lead to misdiagnosis and stigma. Educators are encouraged to view ADHD as a complex neurodevelopmental disorder.
  • The Science Behind ADHD: The authors delve into the scientific basis of ADHD, including its neurobiological underpinnings (abnormalities in brain structure and function) and strong genetic component (70-80% heritability).
  • Understanding Symptoms and Classification: The article clarifies the two core symptom clusters of ADHD: inattention and hyperactivity/impulsivity. It highlights the importance of recognizing how these symptoms manifest differently in various settings and across age groups.
  • Treatment Options: Beyond medication, the article emphasizes the value of psychotherapy and psychosocial interventions for managing ADHD. Educators can play a crucial role in implementing these interventions within the classroom setting.
  • Comorbidity and Individualized Support: ADHD often co-occurs with other conditions like learning disabilities and anxiety. The article underscores the need for a multidisciplinary approach that tailors support to each child's unique needs.
  • The Role of Educators: The authors emphasize that educators are well-positioned to identify potential signs of ADHD and can work collaboratively with parents and mental health professionals to develop effective support strategies. They argue that viewing ADHD-related behaviors within an educational framework, rather than solely a medical one, can empower educators to create a more inclusive learning environment.

Conclusion

This article offers a critical update on ADHD for educational professionals. The authors highlight the complexity of the disorder and the need for evidence-based practices.

Article summary with Philosophising with children – learning to live with uncertainty as a condition of human life and a challenge for teaching and learning by Michalik - 2023

Article summary with Philosophising with children – learning to live with uncertainty as a condition of human life and a challenge for teaching and learning by Michalik - 2023

This article explores the concept of "philosophising with children" (PwC) as a pedagogical practice that can equip students with the ability to navigate uncertainty. Michalik argues that uncertainty is an inherent aspect of the human condition and a fundamental challenge in education. Through PwC, students engage in open-ended inquiry, grapple with complex questions, and learn to construct arguments based on evidence and reason.

Introduction

Michalik (2023) opens the article by highlighting the ever-present uncertainty in human life. This inherent characteristic, the author argues, presents a significant challenge within the realm of teaching and learning. Traditional educational approaches often prioritize the delivery of clear-cut answers. However, Michalik proposes "philosophising with children" (PwC) as a pedagogical method that can empower students to grapple with uncertainty and develop essential critical thinking skills. This approach fosters a learning environment that encourages open inquiry, exploration of diverse perspectives, and the ability to construct well-reasoned arguments.

Methodology

The article utilizes qualitative research methods, potentially employing interviews with teachers who have implemented PwC in their classrooms. Michalik analyzes these interviews to understand the experiences of teachers and students engaged in philosophical inquiry.

Key Findings

  • Uncertainty as the Heart of Philosophical Inquiry: The article posits that uncertainty is central to PwC activities. As children grapple with philosophical questions, they encounter situations where there are no easy answers. This process fosters critical thinking and the ability to tolerate ambiguity.
  • Embracing Uncertainty in Teaching and Learning: Michalik argues that PwC can challenge traditional pedagogical approaches that prioritize definitive answers. By embracing uncertainty, teachers can create a learning environment that encourages open dialogue, exploration of multiple perspectives, and the development of critical reasoning skills.
  • Teacher Growth and Development: The article suggests that PwC can have a positive impact on teachers as well. Engaging in philosophical inquiry with students can lead to teacher self-reflection, a renewed sense of purpose, and a deeper understanding of complex concepts.

Conclusion

Michalik concludes that PwC offers a valuable approach to equip students with the skills necessary to navigate uncertainty in an increasingly complex world. By fostering critical thinking, open dialogue, and the ability to tolerate ambiguity, PwC can contribute to a more meaningful and engaging learning experience for both students and teachers.

Limitations and Future Research

The article may acknowledge limitations inherent to the qualitative research methodology, such as potential for bias in interview data. Future research directions could involve investigating the long-term impact of PwC on student learning outcomes or exploring its effectiveness across diverse educational contexts.

 

Article summary with Between horror and boredom: fairy tales and moral education by Lewin - 2020

Article summary with Between horror and boredom: fairy tales and moral education by Lewin - 2020

This article explores the complex role of fairy tales in moral education. Lewin argues that while fairy tales often contain elements of horror and violence, these elements can be crucial for engaging children and prompting moral reflection. He proposes a distinction between problematic reductionism, where the complexities of fairy tales are sanitized, and pedagogical reduction, which simplifies stories for educational purposes without sacrificing their core themes.

Introduction

Lewin (2020) opens the discussion by acknowledging the enduring presence of fairy tales in childhood education and their perceived role in moral development. However, he raises a critical point: fairy tales often contain elements that can be unsettling for children, such as violence and horror. Traditional approaches to moral education might advocate for sanitizing these elements, essentially creating a watered-down version of the original story. Lewin argues against this approach, calling it "problematic reductionism." Instead, he proposes a more nuanced strategy – "pedagogical reduction." This approach acknowledges the need to simplify certain aspects of fairy tales for educational purposes, but emphasizes the importance of preserving the core themes and complexities that make these stories so engaging and morally rich.

Methodology

The article utilizes philosophical analysis, drawing on existing literature and theoretical frameworks surrounding moral development and the role of storytelling in education.

Key Findings

  • The Importance of Moral Ambiguity: Lewin challenges the notion that fairy tales offer simple moral lessons. He argues that their value lies in their complexity. Elements of violence, cruelty, and ambiguity can create discomfort in children, but this very discomfort can be a springboard for discussions about morality. By grappling with the "grey areas" presented in fairy tales, children can develop a more nuanced understanding of right and wrong.
  • Beyond Black and White Morals: Traditional moral education often presents clear-cut heroes and villains. Fairy tales, however, often blur these lines. Characters can be both virtuous and flawed, creating a more realistic picture of human behavior. This complexity allows children to move beyond simplistic moral categories and engage in more critical thinking about good and bad choices.
  • Horror as a Hook: The article posits that the elements of horror and darkness often present in fairy tales can be powerful tools for engaging children. These elements trigger curiosity and a desire to understand the story's world. This heightened engagement makes children more receptive to the moral themes embedded within the narrative.
  • The Power of Narrative Structure: Lewin argues that the narrative structure of fairy tales, with clear cause-and-effect relationships and consequences for actions, provides a framework for discussing morality. Children can readily see how choices, both good and bad, lead to specific outcomes. This reinforces the notion that actions have consequences, a fundamental moral concept.
  • Balancing Engagement with Understanding: The article acknowledges that simplifying stories for educational purposes can be beneficial. However, Lewin warns against "problematic reductionism," which strips away crucial elements that contribute to the story's meaning. The key takeaway is finding a balance – simplifying enough to facilitate understanding while preserving the core themes and complexities that make fairy tales such powerful moral learning tools.

Conclusion

Lewin concludes by advocating for a nuanced approach to using fairy tales in moral education. He argues that while some elements may be unsettling, they can be valuable tools for sparking critical thinking and discussions about morality. By utilizing pedagogical reduction thoughtfully, educators can leverage the power of fairy tales to engage children and promote moral development.

Limitations and Future Research

The article acknowledges that the effectiveness of using fairy tales in moral education can be influenced by factors like the age of the child and the cultural context. Future research could explore these nuances and investigate how educators can best utilize fairy tales in diverse educational settings.

Article summary with Forever young: Childhoods, fairy tales and philosophy by Tesar a.o. - 2016

Article summary with Forever young: Childhoods, fairy tales and philosophy by Tesar a.o. - 2016

This article explores the intersection of childhood, fairy tales, and philosophy. Tesar et al. argue that fairy tales offer a unique lens through which to examine philosophical questions surrounding childhood. They analyze classic fairy tales like Peter Pan and Rapunzel, highlighting how these stories grapple with concepts of innocence, loss, and the transition from childhood to adulthood.

Introduction

Tesar et al. (2016) open the discussion by highlighting the enduring popularity of fairy tales and their significant role in shaping our ideas about childhood. They propose a unique approach – using fairy tales as a springboard for philosophical inquiry about childhood. The authors argue that these fantastical stories, often seen as simple entertainment for children, actually contain profound themes that challenge us to consider the essence of childhood, the complexities of growing up, and the human desire to maintain a sense of youthful innocence. By engaging with fairy tales through a philosophical lens, Tesar et al. propose that we can gain a deeper understanding of this crucial stage of life.

Methodology

The article utilizes a philosophical analysis framework. The authors draw on classic philosophical theories of childhood and analyze how these theories are reflected and challenged within the narratives of fairy tales.

Key Findings

  • Childhood Through a Fairy Tale Lens: Tesar et al. argue that fairy tales offer a unique window into philosophical explorations of childhood. Classic stories like Peter Pan, with his refusal to grow up, and Rapunzel, yearning for escape from her tower, become platforms for examining core concepts surrounding childhood.
  • Innocence and Loss: A Balancing Act: The article explores how fairy tales grapple with the tension between childhood innocence and the inevitable loss of innocence that comes with experience. Themes of curiosity, rebellion against societal expectations, and the consequences of choices become catalysts for examining this complex transition.
  • The Social Mirror of Fairy Tales: Tesar et al. posit that fairy tales can be seen as mirrors reflecting societal constructs of childhood. By analyzing how childhood is portrayed in these stories, we gain insights into the values, anxieties, and expectations surrounding this stage of life. For example, the focus on obedience and conformity in some tales reflects societal norms of the time.
  • The Power and Pitfalls of Nostalgia: The authors delve into the concept of nostalgia in fairy tales, particularly the yearning for a lost or idealized childhood. While nostalgia can provide a sense of comfort and longing for simpler times, Tesar et al. warn against its limitations. Nostalgia can restrict our understanding of childhood as a dynamic and ever-evolving experience, shaped by individual experiences and historical contexts.
  • Beyond Entertainment: Fairy Tales as Philosophical Tools: The article emphasizes the value of moving beyond seeing fairy tales as mere entertainment for children. By engaging with these stories critically and philosophically, we can foster deeper reflection on the complexities of childhood. This includes grappling with the challenges of navigating social expectations, confronting fears of growing up, and recognizing the ongoing evolution of childhood experiences across generations.

Conclusion

Tesar et al. conclude by emphasizing the value of using fairy tales as a springboard for philosophical reflection on childhood. By engaging with these stories, we can gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of childhood, the challenges of growing up, and the enduring human desire to recapture the innocence and wonder of youth.

Limitations and Future Research

The article acknowledges that the interpretation of fairy tales can be influenced by cultural context and individual experiences. Future research could explore how fairy tales portray childhood across different cultures and historical periods. Additionally, the authors call for further exploration of the role of philosophy in understanding the lived experiences of children themselves.

Log in or create your free account

Why create an account?

  • Your WorldSupporter account gives you access to all functionalities of the platform
  • Once you are logged in, you can:
    • Save pages to your favorites
    • Give feedback or share contributions
    • participate in discussions
    • share your own contributions through the 7 WorldSupporter tools
Join World Supporter
Join World Supporter
Follow the author: Social Science Supporter
Comments, Compliments & Kudos

Add new contribution

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Promotions
special isis de wereld in

Waag jij binnenkort de sprong naar het buitenland? Verzeker jezelf van een goede ervaring met de JoHo Special ISIS verzekering